Skeptical analysis
While some accept ghosts as a reality, many others are skeptical
of ghosts' actuality.
Skeptics may seek to explain ghost sightings by applying the principle
of Occam's razor, which argues that the simplest adequate explanation
for any event or phenomenon is the most likely explanation.
This usually means that first the sincerity and motive of the person
reporting will be called into question. For example, lingering of
ghosts is typically associated with seeking justice or revenge.
Ascribing such motives and powers to dead people could be interpreted
as a scare tactic directed at those who might consider murdering
someone.
Second, the possibility of a hoax or con will be considered, with
the reporting person assumed to be the victim. It seems possible
that, sometimes, the telling of ghost stories might have been a
way for secluded communities to scare off intruders. It is also
conceivable that, when unsuccessful, this tactic could have been
enhanced by more or less elaborate setups with members of that community
playing ghosts.
Third, explanations grounded in knowledge about human physiology
will be proffered. For instance, the appearance of ghosts is often
associated with a chilling sensation and pale, semitransparent figures.
But a natural animal response to fear is hair raising, which could
be mistaken for chill.
The visual aspects of ghost reports could also be accounted for
by human physiology: the peripheral vision is very sensitive in
detecting motion, but does not contain much color or provide focused
shapes; therefore, a moving curtain or other movement outside the
focused view can create a strong illusion of an eerie figure.
The natural occurrence of infrasound, which are sounds below human
auditory frequencies (below 20 hertz), could possibly explain the
notions of feeling a "presence" in the room, or unexplained
feelings of anxiety or dread, as certain infrasonic frequencies
are known to have these effects on the body.
Psychological factors are also often cited as natural explanations
for ghost sightings: susceptible people might be prone to exaggerated
interpretations of perceptions when visiting a site of unpleasant
historical events. Certain images such as paintings and movies might
"program" a person to automatically associate a certain
structure or area as haunted because of what he has seen in the
movies.
|